I HAVE no doubts that there are problems on both sides of this argument about the ferries fiasco. The SNP initially were trying to save jobs, but I believe that they should have taken some additional advice from business groups/individuals to make sure that they had the best deal possible to get the ferries built and for the future of the yard.

However, I certainly would not take any advice from the Tories or indeed listen to their mumping and moaning, considering they had an MP (Grayling) award ferry contracts to a company that did not have any ships! They seem to have forgotten about that.

READ MORE: Kate Forbes: McColl has 'clear interest' in shifting blame around ferry delays

As far as Jim McColl spitting out the dummy and saying that he has changed his position in supporting independence, this says a lot about the man. Anyone who wants independence for Scotland want it for the people of Scotland and the generations to follow, so they can have a more prosperous and fairer country and the newly elected government of an independent Scotland will be responsible for making decisions and laws to benefit our country. So why has he changed his mind??

Neil Harrison
Biggar