ISN’T George M Mitchell (Letters, June 9) advocating retention of the not proven verdict on the basis of “we know you did it but can’t quite prove it” the very reason why it should be dispensed with?

If a case can’t be proven, why should anyone suffer the smear of guilt hanging over them like a sword of Damocles? What gives anyone the right to second guess justice?

As one who was offended against, I suffered such a verdict being handed down against me. After an altercation because of their poor behaviour, one of two passengers who’d left my cab launched himself at it, ran 20 metres and did a perfect stunt roll over the bonnet as I was leaving the drop-off point. In fear of further attack I removed myself from the scene, reported the incident to the police and awaited their arrival.

READ MORE: 'Very strong case' for abolishing Not Proven verdict, Justice Secretary says

Two against one, and despite their travelling up from London together at taxpayers’ expense they couldn’t tell the same story under cross-examination. I just told the truth.

However, the judge was clearly thinking along Mr Mitchell’s lines and returned a summary verdict of not proven, which I raised with my lawyer as being unsatisfactory. He simply dismissed me, satisfied with it being an acquittal; this junior counsel delighted to return to his chambers with a victory in a case he was likely expected to lose given it was two witnesses against just me.

The fact is, I was offended against and despite rightly seeking the help of the police, potentially losing my licence and livelihood and being dragged through a worrying court appearance based on the falsehoods of two liars, the judge sending his message to me – and presumably to all cabbies – in a case that was never proven was unwelcome. I no longer sit on a jury because of my experiences of the justice system, incurred through doing a difficult job with members of the public.

Proven or not proven. Guilty or not guilty. Either will do, we just don’t need the mixture with the ridiculous and unfair connotation that Mr Mitchell and this judge attach to the not proven verdict.

Jim Taylor
Edinburgh