I FIND the contents of Martin Hannan’s report (Professor slams group of pro-indy academics, July 22) disappointing as it could be interpreted as a slip in standards.

READ MORE: Author of 'neverendum' paper slams group of pro-indy academics

Early at the beginning of the second half of last century, Professor Norman Sidwell put in a tremendous effort to establish degree courses for the construction industry and its related professions and pioneered research in these areas. Heriot-Watt University became globally acknowledged as one of the leading centres for construction education and research. Professor Sidwell was followed by a stream of other talented academics who built upon his work and further developed the university’s standing.

The latest stushie involving Professor Colin Jones and other colleagues, regarding his paper “Neverendum”, is not helpful to the university’s reputation. What is not clear is whether or not Jones’s research was funded and if so by whom. In addition, did Jones receive payment from The Times?

Thomas L Inglis
Fintry